Skip to content

EP Comments

EP Comments is a proper comment system for PageMotor. Database-backed, admin moderation queue, threaded replies with email notifications, spam protection via honeypot and rate limiting, Gravatar avatars, and a WordPress-to-PageMotor comment import path.

Published by ElmsPark Studio.

Comments attach to pages via a shortcode. Each page has a content-options toggle to enable or disable comments on that specific page, so you can let readers comment on blog posts but not on sales pages.

Features:

  • Threaded replies. Reply to a comment and the parent commenter gets an email.
  • Moderation queue. New comments start as pending by default. Admin reviews, approves, or rejects.
  • Auto-approve option for sites where moderation is overkill, plus trusted returning commenters detection so regulars don’t queue every time.
  • Honeypot spam protection on the form.
  • IP-based rate limiting with a configurable interval.
  • CSRF protection via double-submit cookie.
  • Gravatars with initial-based fallback for commenters without one.
  • Schema.org DiscussionForumPosting structured data for SEO.
  • WordPress comment import from JSON so you can bring years of discussion across.
  • Auto-close comments on posts older than N days.
  • PageMotor 0.8.2b or later
  • EP Suite base class (bundled)
  • EP Email (optional but recommended for styled notification emails; without it, the plugin falls back to PHP’s mail())
  1. ep-comments.zip comes with an EP Suite licence — ElmsPark supplies it directly (see EP Suite plugins); after install it updates through your site’s Updates screen.
  2. Upload via Plugins → Manage Plugins. Activate.
  3. Drop the [comments] shortcode on any page where you want comments.
ShortcodePurpose
[comments]Full comment list for the current page, plus the submission form.
[comment-form]Form only, no list. Useful if you want the form above the list (default is below).

On any page’s content options:

  • Enable comments. Checkbox. Default can be set globally; this overrides per page.

Pages without comments enabled won’t render the [comments] shortcode, even if the shortcode is present in the content.

Accessed through EP Suite nav → Comments.

SettingPurpose
Admin notification emailWhere admin-alert emails go when new comments are submitted.
Auto-approveOn: comments appear immediately without moderation. Off: comments queue for admin review.
Trusted returning commenter detectionWhen a commenter has N previously-approved comments under the same email, subsequent comments auto-approve even if global auto-approve is off.
HoneypotOn by default. Adds a hidden form field that bots fill but humans don’t. Submissions with the honeypot populated are rejected silently.
Rate limit intervalSeconds between comments from the same IP. Default 60.
Comments per pagePagination size. Default 20.
Display orderNewest first or oldest first.
Auto-close after N daysLocks comments on pages older than this.

The admin dashboard lists every comment with:

  • Filtering by status (Pending / Approved / Spam / Trash).
  • Search by commenter name, email, or body text.
  • Pagination.
  • Bulk actions: approve, unapprove, mark as spam, trash, delete permanently.

Clicking a comment shows full context including the commenter’s history on your site.

A commenter clicks Reply under any approved comment. Their reply is submitted with a parent_id reference. When approved:

  • The reply is rendered nested under its parent in the comment list.
  • The parent commenter gets an email notification telling them their comment was replied to, with a link back to the page.

Three layers, applied in order:

  1. Honeypot. If the hidden field has a value, the submission is rejected. Most bots fill every field.
  2. Rate limit. Same IP cannot post faster than the configured interval.
  3. CSRF via double-submit cookie. Cross-site forms posting to your comments endpoint are rejected.

Bots that pass all three are rare. If you see any that do, they go through moderation (unless auto-approve is on) so no damage is done.

The plugin looks up each commenter’s email against Gravatar. If they have one, their avatar renders next to their comment. If they don’t, a coloured initial-letter circle renders instead (based on the first letter of their name, with a deterministic background colour).

There is no import button on the settings page yet. When we move a WordPress site to PageMotor, we export its comments and import them for you.

  • Each comment is matched to its page by the page’s address, so the page must already exist on the new site.
  • Replies stay under the comment they answered, however deep the thread went in WordPress.
  • Comments still waiting for approval come across as pending, ready for you to approve or remove.
  • Running the import again does not add duplicates.
  • Comments show on a page wherever the [ep-comments] shortcode is placed.

Check the page has Enable comments ticked in its content options, and that the [comments] shortcode is actually in the page body.

“Admin notifications aren’t arriving”

Section titled ““Admin notifications aren’t arriving””

Install and configure EP Email. The plugin’s own mail() fallback often fails on modern hosts because raw PHP mail() is blocked or spam-filtered. EP Email with proper SMTP fixes this.

“Commenter got a reply notification for a reply to their own comment”

Section titled ““Commenter got a reply notification for a reply to their own comment””

That’s the design — someone replied to their comment, they should know. If you don’t want that for some category of replies, the feature request can go in the review queue.

“All new comments are queuing as pending even though I turned auto-approve on”

Section titled ““All new comments are queuing as pending even though I turned auto-approve on””

Check the global auto-approve setting saved correctly. Also check the trusted-returning-commenter threshold is 0 or low; if it’s high, first-timers still queue.

“A specific commenter keeps being marked as pending despite being trusted”

Section titled ““A specific commenter keeps being marked as pending despite being trusted””

They may be submitting from different email addresses or different IPs. Trust is tied to email + approved history. Same commenter with three emails has three trust records.

Drop the rate limit to 120 or 300 seconds. Investigate specific IPs with the moderation dashboard’s IP filter and block persistent offenders at the nginx or Cloudflare level.

For a quick question about this plugin, EP Support inside your admin is the fastest option. The chat widget sits on every EP plugin settings page and knows which one you’re on, with starter questions and links preloaded for that exact screen.

For anything bigger — a bug report, a feature request, or a “how do I…” that needs a real reply — open a ticket at help.elmspark.com. A real person, helped by AI, writes the reply. Usually within a few hours. Tickets don’t disappear into the void.

  • Changing this plugin’s settings over the API now needs an admin token. Producer tokens and AI apps connected through a producer account can still read the settings. Saving from the Admin screen works exactly as before.

A security update. Please install it.

  • Returning commenters must be signed in to skip moderation. With Trust Returning Commenters on, a comment is published straight away only when the commenter is signed in under an address that already has an approved comment.
  • Avatars default to initials. Gravatar sends every reader’s browser to gravatar.com and publishes a fingerprint of each commenter’s email, so new and unset sites now use initials. A site that chose Gravatar keeps it.
  • Importing WordPress comments now works. The import stopped with an internal error on current PHP, so no comments came across. It now brings them in, and running it again does not add duplicates.
  • Replies stay replies. An imported reply is shown under the comment it answered, instead of as a separate comment.
  • Replies to replies are shown. A reply more than one level deep, as WordPress allows, used to be saved but never shown. It now appears in the thread, straight after the comment it answers.
  • Imported comment text reads cleanly. Links in a WordPress comment keep their address in brackets after the link text, rather than showing raw code.
  • Requires PageMotor 0.11.5.
  • Settings language menu. The language menu in this plugin’s settings now lists only the languages it is actually translated into, plus English, so you can no longer pick a language that changes nothing.
  • New-comment emails name the right page again. The email you receive when someone comments said the page was “Unknown” on PageMotor 0.9 and later. It now shows the page’s title.
  • No settings change and nothing to do after updating.
  • Fixes a crash on the comment form when an older EP plugin is installed on the same site. Submitting the form returned an internal error and nothing was saved or sent. EP plugins share one common code library, and whichever copy loads first is the one every EP plugin on that site uses, so a single out-of-date plugin could leave this one calling a spam check its copy did not have. The check now carries its own fallback and no longer depends on another plugin being up to date.
  • No change on a site where this never happened: the same spam check runs, and nothing else changed.
  • Blocks a spam bot that was getting past the form honeypot. The scraper changed its network address on every single request, so blocking by address never caught it, but it always sent a malformed browser identifier that no real browser sends. Forms now reject anything carrying that signature, with the same silent response a caught bot already got.
  • It was not theoretical. One client site had taken 57 fake signups before this went in, and the same bot had hit 17 sites.